Comparing health insurance: understanding what really matters

We know that trying to compare quotes and coverage across medical insurance can feel like a minefield of small print, excesses, add-ons and jargon. Sometimes a quote might look cheap at first glance, but when you dig deeper you discover a high excess, restricted cover, or requirements to wait for NHS treatment before you can access private care.

That’s why at Lateral we aim to make our health plan as easy to understand as possible. There are no add-ons and no options that increase or decrease your premium. Our pricing is transparent and based only on your age. 

We only accept people who are in good health when they join, and to renew your cover we ask you to complete and share the results of your Annual Health Check. This helps us make sure everyone on the plan is taking similar, proactive steps to look after their health.

By encouraging prevention and early monitoring, we’re able to keep premiums steadier over time. It also means you’re less likely to feel that you’re paying more to offset the costs of people who aren’t engaging with their health or making healthier choices.

‍

What to look for when comparing healthcare policies

When comparing policies, it’s important to think about what really matters to you and how you plan to engage with your cover, not just focus on the headline premium.

Below we’ve summarised the key areas worth exploring when thinking about your health cover options and what the Lateral Health Plan’s position is, so you can make the most informed decision.

‍

Excess

We know that some policies offer lower premiums by setting much higher excesses, and for some people that trade-off works. However, a high excess can act as a barrier to seeking private care and significantly reduce the value of your cover. 

Questions to ask yourself:

• Would I expect to be able to use this policy to fund smaller medical interventions such as consultations, diagnostics, physiotherapy? 
• Would a high excess stop me from seeking care via the policy or using the included benefits?
• If I combine the premium and the excess, what is the true price of my annual cover?

‍

The Lateral view:

We don’t want an excess to stand in the way of you deciding whether to seek private care when something concerns you. Our excess is £100 and applies on your first claim for consultations and diagnostics each  year. 

We allow full use of our other covers and benefits e.g. Annual Health Check, dietitian support, virtual GP service, without requiring an excess payment because we believe our health plan should be something that works with you year on year.

‍

Outpatient limit

Outpatient limits are another way to reduce monthly premiums by limiting cover. There are many plans on the market that give options for low, or zero, outpatient limits of £500 or £1,000.  Some diagnostic consultations and tests can cost more than £1,000, so it’s important to consider the outpatient and diagnostics limit carefully when choosing a policy, particularly if you want the reassurance of being able to fully investigate new symptoms without requiring further payments.

Questions to ask yourself:

• Would I expect to pay in addition to my monthly premiums when I need to access private diagnostics or consultations?
• If I exhausted my diagnostics limit, would I be happy to pay privately or I am happy to rely on the NHS here?
• Do I view my insurance as ‘catastrophe cover’ or do I want to use it for the inevitable smaller interventions I may require as I age?

‍

The Lateral view:

‍Our outpatient limit is £2,000 per policy year, resetting each year at renewal. After your excess, this gives you £1,900 available for consultations, scans and diagnostics which should allow our members to fully investigate new, acute issues as they arise. 

‍

Guided vs unguided care

Within private medical insurance, there are typically two pathways to accessing care: guided and unguided:

Unguided care means managing your own pathway; choosing your consultants and hospitals yourself. This offers a high degree of choice but usually comes with minimal support and guidance. Note that you may still be subject to a restricted hospital list. 

Guided care means the insurer chooses the care pathway and provider. This often results in streamlined access to care, and therefore with significantly less freedom of choice. Your insurer will direct where you will be seen and who you see within their network which may not be the most convenient location or your preferred consultant. Guided plans tend to result in lower premiums as the insurer has a higher ability to control their costs by working with providers/consultants where they have secured discounted rates. 

Questions to ask yourself:

• How important is it for me to choose my consultant? Would I prefer to be recommended to a consultant by a friend or my insurer?
• Would I value the opportunity to receive treatment at a place of my choosing? 

‍

The Lateral view:

‍At Lateral, we believe in supporting patient choice and enabling either approach. Our nurse-led navigation team will support you wherever you choose to receive care. You can choose to access care within the Lateral Hospital Network, where we have agreed treatment arrangements, or select your own provider and receive an equivalent contribution up to our agreed maximum per procedure.
For many, the simplicity and certainty of the network appeals, while for others being seen at their chosen hospital is worth exploring and paying any required difference for.
At Lateral, regardless of your decision, our nurse navigation service will help you weigh up the pros and cons of your choice and support arranging your care. Our goal is for you to feel supported until your health issue is resolved or you have a clear healthcare management plan in place.

‍

NHS wait time rules

Some health insurers will offer options that only approve private treatment if NHS waiting times exceed a set threshold. This means you could be paying for your premiums for private insurance but still be required to use the NHS if, for example, an 11-week wait falls within a 12-week waiting threshold.

While choosing these options can significantly reduce your premiums, it can also limit how quickly you’re able to access care when you need it.

Questions to ask yourself:

• If I wanted care quickly, how would I feel if I had to wait several weeks for NHS treatment?
• What are the typical wait times in my local area?

‍

The Lateral view:

We are explicit and transparent about what you can claim for privately and where you need to stay in the NHS (e.g. emergency care, cancer or chronic conditions).

If eligible for private care, you are never required to exhaust NHS options or wait for NHS time thresholds before accessing it and you make the decision yourself. With nurse-led navigation, you can make an informed decision each time: stay within the NHS where it works well, or use private care where speed, convenience, or continuity matter more to you. This flexibility is central to keeping the plan affordable while still making it genuinely useful.

‍

Private cancer cover

We know that the risk of cancer increases as we age. We also know that cancer care within the NHS is excellent.

Private cancer cover does exist, but we’ve designed our plan to work alongside the NHS, providing cover where the NHS care is subject to lengthy wait times. Cancer care is not one of those areas.

Questions to ask yourself:

• Do I have friends who have undergone cancer treatment with the NHS or privately? What were their experiences?
• If I start private cancer treatment, do I want to be locked into a private treatment pathway?
• What does private cancer treatment offer that the NHS does not?

‍

The Lateral view:

‍At Lateral, given the cost of including cancer cover, the potential impact on renewal premiums following a claim, and the strength of NHS cancer services, we’ve chosen not to include cancer cover in our plan. Instead, we have partnered with Reframe who provide expert cancer navigation and support across all cancer types, giving you access to an experienced cancer nurse and a growing library of expert-created resources to support education, wellbeing and recovery. This means, although you will stay in the NHS for cancer treatment, you will have enhanced support that complements your NHS treatment. 

‍

Pre-existing conditions and moratorium underwriting

An important aspect of private medical insurance is how pre-existing medical conditions are treated. These are conditions you had before taking out the policy. 

There is no standard industry approach, which makes policies difficult to compare like for like. Many insurers exclude conditions that occurred within the previous three to five years, and typically only consider covering them again after a 24-month moratorium wait period. 

This can lead to confusion and disappointment at the time of claim, especially when there are long look back periods. 

Questions to ask yourself:

• How many conditions have I had in the last 5 years that might resurface?
• Were these conditions quite broad or very specific? Might that impact the interpretation of a pre-existing condition resurfacing?
  
  

The Lateral view:

‍At Lateral, we took a different approach. We only look at conditions that occurred in the two years before you bought your policy, and these are excluded for just the first 12 months of cover. 

To read more about our position on pre-existing conditions, please see our FAQs. 

‍

Do I want my health plan to be proactive or reactive?‍

‍Health insurers differ in their approach to how they want you to engage with the product. Some incentivise healthy habits and early diagnosis to prevent longer-term complications. Others are there in case the worst happens and do not encourage you to seek regular check-ups. This entirely depends on the insurer's commercial strategy and what’s important to you. 

Questions to ask yourself:

• Does the plan include ways to understand your health better, even if you feel fine?
• Are the excess and limits intended to limit access to early, lower cost care?

‍

The Lateral view:

‍Looking after your health becomes increasingly important with age, particularly through early identification of potential issues so that problems can be addressed before they affect day-to-day function. For this reason, the plan includes a comprehensive Annual Health Check worth £362, providing a structured overview of key health metrics that can be tracked consistently year after year.

Early detection alone is not sufficient. Maintaining health and mobility after 60 often depends on ongoing lifestyle management as well as medical insight. The plan therefore includes access to nutritionists and physiotherapists to support practical, evidence-based changes to diet, movement, and physical resilience.

We recognise that healthy ageing may require adjustments to established habits. Our clinical team continuously reviews the evidence on ageing and prevention to ensure that guidance and support are aligned with current best practice, helping members maintain health, independence, and activity levels over time.